In Memoriam

Remembering Chef Judi Gallagher

Our longtime food editor Judi Gallagher died last week. Sarasota Magazine’s editors, writers and publisher sent in their memories. We will miss her.

April 13, 2026

Chef Judi Gallagher

Chef Judi Gallagher passed away last week. A one-woman tour de force, Gallagher was a hospitality consultant, the food editor of this magazine, the author of the cookbook Recipes and Reflections of Chef Judi, and the culinary director at ABC7, where she hosted a weekly cooking show and a live Friday show, "Chef Judi's Dish," highlighting local restaurants and making herself at home in viewers' lives. 

Today, we all know the word "influencer," but Gallagher was a proto-influencer. She was blogging and using social media and video long before it became the  juggernaut it is today. That makes sense—she loved sharing, whether it was a bite of a dish she was eating, a piece of news or a culinary tip. And on every platform—print, television, social—she was uniquely herself: kind, loving, quick to laugh but even quicker to uplift others. We will miss her.

"Judi Didn't Just Enter a Space—She Lifted It"

"Every time Judi walked into the building, it felt like someone had cracked open a can of ginger ale. First, that unmistakable pop—an arrival you couldn’t ignore. Then the effervescence: bright, lively, a spark that tickled the room and stayed with you long after. Judi was like that. She didn’t just enter a space—she lifted it.

"Dining out with her was its own kind of performance. Sitting across from Judi, you knew you were in the presence of someone who understood food—not just how it tasted, but how it should be experienced. It always brought to mind that deli scene from When Harry Met Sally—the certainty, the delight, the authority. You found yourself thinking, without hesitation, I’ll have what she’s having.

"Judi was truly larger than life—not just in presence, but in the way she engaged with the world. Fully. Joyfully. Without holding back.

"And when you lose someone like that, someone who carried that kind of energy, you feel the absence in a real way. The room is quieter. The air a little flatter.

"But maybe the best way to honor Judi isn’t just to remember her—it’s to carry her forward. To keep a piece of that spirit. That effervescence. That joy. To walk into a room and, in some small way, open it up the way she did.

"That’s how she stays with us." —Kelley Lavin

"I Instantly Wanted to Know Her"

"I met Judi Gallagher through her husband Paul Gallagher in 1997. My husband Larry and I were part of a group of parents who hammered out a blueprint for the county’s first charter school, the Sarasota School of Arts and Sciences (SSAS), and Paul was our first principal.

"I was taken with Paul’s knowledge of curriculum, child development and administrative skills, and we are friends to this day. But, truth be told, Paul’s sartorial taste ran to the rumpled, professorial side; he was never going to walk down a fashion runway.

"Judi, I soon found out, was another story. At an SSAS meet-and-greet for parents and students right after Paul was hired, Judi walked in, all 6-foot, 1-inch of her, in a colorful dress perfectly coordinated with accessories, blonde hair coiffed and piled on her head, perfect makeup and a huge smile.  She was a showstopper. As an editor at Sarasota Magazine even back then, I instantly wanted to know her.

"In no time, once we discovered her food background, Judi became part of the magazine family. She wrote weekly blogs about restaurants and the local food scene, regularly burst in to announce her latest cuisine discoveries, gave us juicy gossip and gushed about the next Bruce Springsteen concert she was planning her life around. She also created lavish dinner gatherings for editors at different restaurants—I remember a Beach Bistro dinner where the entire menu had some sort of olive oil theme and a lot of good wine. (She always arranged for a van to transport us on these adventures, so we didn’t have to drive home after a night of wine and food.)

"Whenever I’d walk into a restaurant with her, especially after she became Chef Judi Gallagher at WWSB and hosted weekly cooking shows with local chefs, we were treated as celebrities. She was impossible to miss with her stature and generous laugh. She always knew what to order, and I loved her side dishes about whether the chef and customer service were up to her standards. I was also a guest at her home gatherings, and her entertaining style and cooking were as delightful and stress free as only someone who understands hospitality and loves people can make them.

"Judi was a force. She brought people together. She knew that good food, conversation and laughter brought out the best in us. We cherished her at the magazine, and I will miss her light and love of life." —Susan Burns

"I love my job!!!" Gallagher captioned this photo—an emotion that was evident in everything she did.

"A True Mensch"

"I barely knew Judi Gallagher when she offered me a car.

"This was more than a decade ago. At the time, I was a freelance journalist who had developed a focus on food writing, and because of our mutual interest in tasty meals, I had gotten to know Judi a bit—mostly through gluttonous lunches she used to organize for food media people at various restaurants around town.

"For years, I had watched her on TV and read her writing, so when she first invited me to some of those gatherings, she intimidated me. Judi was a bona fide local celebrity, and she wanted my opinion on some new menu item? What I didn’t know then was that Judi was a genius at making people feel welcomed and included. Meals with her were dominated by conversations about family and friends and loaded with gossip about the restaurant industry and the local media scene in equal measure—delicious, in every sense.

"And then my car broke down. Permanently. It was July, hot, and I was carting around a 3-year-old and a 9-month-old. I issued a plea on Facebook for a tip on a used vehicle, and Judi messaged me immediately. Her son Eric wasn’t using his car at the moment—maybe I could drive his for a few weeks while I figured out a solution? She told me to meet her at Phillippi Creek Oyster Bar at noon a couple days later (because why not make a meal out of it?) and she would hand over the keys.

"This floored me. To lend someone your car for an extended period of time is no small gesture. But I shouldn’t have been surprised—that was who Judi was. She was always eager to introduce you to someone she knew who could help you out or put in a good word for you with so-and-so. If you were in her circle, you were in it, and she wanted to take care of you and see you succeed—a true mensch." —Cooper Levey-Baker

"Eating and Shopping—What We Did Best"

"Judi and I were compatible travel buddies—our destinations being food events, conferences, restaurants and such that we would eventually write about, often for this magazine. We shamelessly overpacked (lots of hair care products) and did not mind getting lost. We talked to strangers and would take any detour in our rented car if it led to a pie kitchen. A Judi obsession was to find the perfect apple pie. We tasted pies in posh hotels, dumpy roadside cafes, city bakeries and at pie contests, all on our way to doing something else entirely.

"And we could shop like we were born to it. A favorite trip for us was a summer Maine lobster festival—four days in Kennebunkport eating lobster for breakfast lunch and dinner at sit-down tasting menus, posh homes that hosted famous chefs, cocktail parties, diners that locals recommended and lobster shacks often located near lighthouses. And, we shopped for handbags, shoes, gorgeous pottery, silver summer jewelry and lobster-themed objects. 

"The day we were to fly home, we each packed a large suitcase and our carry-ons and our new roomy designer handbags. That still left an imposing stuff-mound  on the floor. We had no choice; we pushed it all into plastic bags and dashed to the quaint post office. It was Saturday and they closed at noon. We grabbed cardboard boxes and started filling them. Postal staff helped seal and label. We made the noon deadline and headed to the airport. No pie signs so we didn’t have to stop.

"Two weeks later, four cardboard boxes arrived and we sat on the floor and pulled out dirty laundry, cookbooks, high-heel suede boots (hers), city magazines, red lobster pot holders, lobster placemats, watercolor notecards of coastal Maine. Each thing we touched made us laugh and remember some situation it triggered. Our tangible memories of eating and shopping. It’s what we did best."  —Marsha Fottler

"She Had Her Finger on the Pulse of Everything Food-Related"

"Whenever Judi came into the magazine office, it was a chance to put aside whatever else you were working on and spend some fun time catching up with what Judi knew. She had her finger on the pulse of everything food-related in town—the latest news on restaurants and chefs and changes—and her gusto for good food, good conversation and life in general was too infectious not to share. And whether in the office or over a great lunch or dinner elsewhere, Judi was so lively, so generous and so enthusiastic, you came away on a high note. Sarasota is a sadder place without her." —Kay Kipling

Gallagher with actor and food personality Stanley Tucci as part of Tucci's appearance at Ringling College's Town Hall Lecture Series in 2024.

"The Suncoast's Version of Julia Child"

“'You know Judi Gallagher?'

"That was the reaction from more than a few people when they found out that I was friends with Judi, who made herself at home in their lives each week via her blog posts for this magazine and her cooking segments on ABC7. I understood why. The Suncoast’s version of Julia Child—with the joy, appetite and height to match—Judi often seemed  larger than life. But the real person was even more magnetic than what her audiences saw or read. Kind, funny and loyal, if she took you under her wing, you felt like the luckiest person in the world. That’s what she did for me: during a rough patch in 2009, I began helping her out with her consulting business. Hours in front of the computer quickly turned into hours spent at her dinner table with her beloved husband, Paul, and their dogs. As the years passed, our relationship deepened. We talked about food, of course, but also family, life and business; how she built a successful baking company in Boston, from the ground up, and then did the same when she moved to Sarasota and started her restaurant consulting firm. She began to call me her 'adopted daughter,' and hearing that felt like sunshine.

"One of my favorite memories is of attending a Hanukkah party at her house, where she became a one-woman latke assembly line, frying dozens of hot potato pancakes for her guests while also managing to be fully present for them at the same time. I can still picture her that night: standing in her apron with a spatula in one hand, blonde hair piled on top of her head, basking in the glow of the holidays and the people who loved her. I remember her asking if everyone had enough food and can hear her full-throated laugh. Oh, and the latkes were perfect." —Megan McDonald

Gallagher at Phillippi Creek Oyster Bar, 2022

"Judi Became My Mermaid"

"I interviewed Judi for a Sarasota Magazine profile back in the early 2000s. After eating lunch, we sat on the curb outside of Simon’s Restaurant on S. Tamiami Trail because we couldn’t stop talking. We bonded over being Jewish mothers; loving a chewy bagel with a cream cheese schmear; a taste for Chinese soup dumplings; fashion, and travel.

"Plus, a shared tragedy.

"We both lost our beloved younger sisters to sudden illness way too early. Judi’s Hilary and my Tracy were forever frozen in our memories as perfect siblings and our best friends. Just as we started to cry together, the sprinklers came on in the bushes behind us, and we were drenched trying to escape. We laughed so hard we peed ourselves. That was the day Judi became my 'mermaid.'

"Judi adored every animal and human she met. Her greatest pleasure was inviting hordes of friends and family to her overflowing Thanksgiving feasts crowned by dozens of desserts sent to her by grateful PR clients as a way to say “thank you” for publicizing their restaurants and boosting their success. And always, apple pie baked by son Eric, often on the Big Green Egg.

"I was so lucky to be Judi’s friend. It meant gorging on cracked crab and Champagne in a limo while riding from Sarasota to the Beach Bistro Restaurant on Anna Maria Island for a magnificent PR dinner. She was devoted to her clients as well as an abundance of charities, always willing to bake or cook for a cause. When we did our mall walking at UTC, the combination of her height, shiny blond locks and huge smile made her instantly recognizable. I remember one man leaning over the balcony from the second floor and hollering, 'Hey, Chef Judi. I just made your mother’s brisket!'

"Salvatore Ferragamo. Roy Yamaguchi. Her camera man at ABC 7. The restaurant servers to whom she always left gigantic tips when she was comped for a meal. No one will ever forget this loving, giving woman with a heart as big as the garbage can lid-sized pizzas auctioned at the Florida Winefest & Auction that she helped establish.

"Swim free now, my cherished mermaid." —Ruth Lando

"She Never Met a Stranger or Passed Up the Opportunity to Help"

"Years ago, I was an aspiring recipe developer with a blog that I’m glad has been lost to time. Everyone knew who Judi was because she was a star in Sarasota’s food scene. I knew her by sight—she was tall and graceful and always smiling—but not personally.

"Then I met her late nephew at a party, and was star-struck when he brought up his Aunt Judi. He was gracious and entertained my unending questions.

"After that party, he set up a coffee date for Judi and me to meet so that I could ask her for advice as an aspiring food professional. She was so gracious to accept, and we spent two hours outside of Buddy Brew talking food and laughing like we’d known each other our whole lives. That was the thing about Judi, she never met a stranger, and she never passed up the opportunity to help.

"Judi checked in regularly throughout the years as I picked up a bit of writing work. Aside from my own family, I think she celebrated my getting an editorial position at this magazine more than anyone else, and set about introducing me to everyone she knew. She’d take me to lunches with enough food for 20 people, just the two of us. Everyone in the restaurant as taken with her as I had been—and still was.

"Once I got up to speed with the magazine, we texted weekly about what we were working on and our shared friends—always with a quip to make the other laugh. Were it not for Judi’s encouragement, I doubt I’d be where I am today." —Lauren Jackson

"She Believed Food Brings People Together"

"Judi had great passion for food as a way to bring people together. She will be greatly missed." —Ilene Denton

Filed under
Share
Show Comments