Sarasota-Manatee Home Prices Rise as Luxury Sales Surge and Lower-Priced Sales Decline
Image: Three Sixty Views
There's good news in Sarasota and Manatee's housing market. Homes are selling faster, sellers are getting closer to their asking prices, and median sale prices are climbing. But look a little closer, and the picture gets more complicated.
Million-dollar homes are gaining ground while lower-priced sales are declining. Cash buyers are playing a larger role, especially in Manatee County. And even as homes spend less time on the market, fewer buyers are signing new contracts.
The latest figures from the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee (RASM) show that Sarasota County's median single-family sale price rose 10.1 percent in October to $490,000, compared with $445,000 a year earlier. Yet closed sales fell 5.2 percent to 633 homes.
The divide is more striking at opposite ends of the market. Sales of Sarasota County single-family homes priced at $1 million or more increased 25.6 percent, while transactions below $400,000 declined 19.2 percent.
Lynne Zettergren, a Realtor with Coldwell Banker in downtown Sarasota, believes that reflects the kinds of buyers increasingly drawn to the area.
"I think that it's being perceived as a place for the wealthy," she says.
Zettergren says many prospective buyers are retirees and second-home owners rather than people purchasing their first homes.
But rising median prices don't necessarily mean individual homes are appreciating. Because the median represents the midpoint of completed sales, a greater concentration of expensive transactions can push it higher. Zettergren believes that's part of what's happening as prices stabilize following a period of declines.
The year-to-date numbers offer perspective: Although Sarasota's median single-family sale price jumped 10.1 percent in October, the median for the first 10 months of 2026 was up just 2.9 percent.
Manatee County followed a similar pattern. Its median single-family sale price rose 3.7 percent, to $499,000, slightly higher than Sarasota's, while closed sales edged up 0.8 percent, to 601. Million-dollar home sales increased 18.2 percent, while transactions below $400,000 fell 10.7 percent.
Another important player? The buyer who doesn't need a mortgage.
Across both counties, single-family cash purchases increased 5.1 percent from October 2025, while financed transactions declined 6.3 percent. Manatee drove that increase, with cash purchases jumping 20.4 percent and accounting for nearly one-third of its single-family sales.
Sarasota's cash transactions declined 4.1 percent, although they still represented 40.9 percent of sales.
"We are getting a lot of investors," Zettergren says, describing frequent inquiries from people interested in rental properties.
She doesn't believe cash buyers are necessarily squeezing out mortgage-dependent purchasers. Instead, she sees younger buyers approaching homeownership more cautiously as they contend with higher borrowing costs.
The condo market presents an even more dramatic contrast.
Sarasota County recorded 269 condo and townhome sales in October, up 9.3 percent from a year earlier. The median sale price increased 4.8 percent, to $325,000.
The average sale price, however, soared 63.8 percent, to $770,952.
Before anyone concludes that the typical Sarasota condo suddenly costs three-quarters of a million dollars, consider what happened at the luxury end: There were 36 sales priced at $1 million or more, compared with 16 a year earlier. Nine properties sold for at least $5 million, including three that fetched $10 million or more.
Those exceptional transactions pulled the average upward, while the median offers a more even picture of the broader market.
Zettergren believes the extraordinary luxury numbers may reflect an unusual month, but she also sees signs of stability returning to the condo market after a difficult period.
Following the 2021 Surfside condominium collapse, Florida imposed stricter inspection and reserve-funding requirements on many condo buildings. The resulting repairs and special assessments put financial pressure on owners, particularly in older properties. Zettergren recalls some owners facing assessments of $30,000 to $50,000, prompting those who couldn't afford the costs to sell.
"I think it’s somewhat stabilizing now," she says.
Sarasota's condo and townhome inventory fell 13.7 percent from a year earlier, while the supply of available properties dropped from 7.5 months, to 5.4 months, bringing the market closer to balance.
Manatee's condo market is recovering differently. Sales increased 13.1 percent, to 198 transactions, with most of the growth occurring among properties priced below $500,000. The median price barely moved, rising 0.9 percent, to $295,000.
The distinction is notable: Sarasota's condo sales growth has been driven in part by luxury purchases, while Manatee's has been concentrated at more modest price points.
Still, the recovery follows several years of turbulence. An October analysis by ResiClub found that Sarasota and Manatee were among 12 major Florida counties where condo prices had surrendered more than half the appreciation accumulated during the pandemic housing boom.
Single-family homes have also given back some of those gains, although the condo correction has been more severe. October's stronger numbers, in other words, don't erase the losses that came before them.
Inventory has also tightened over the past year. Sarasota County's supply of single-family homes fell 14.2 percent, to 2,824 listings, representing roughly four months of inventory. Manatee had a similar 4.1-month supply, although its active listings increased slightly.
A market with roughly five to six months of supply is generally considered balanced. Four months tends to favor sellers, while the region's condo market, with just over five months of supply in both counties, offers buyers somewhat more room to negotiate.
Sellers are also receiving a larger share of their original asking prices. In Sarasota, single-family sellers received a median of 95.5 percent, up from 92.4 percent a year earlier. Manatee sellers received 95.8 percent, compared with 94.9 percent.
And homes are moving faster. Sarasota single-family properties spent a median of 40 days on the market before going under contract, down from 61 days. Manatee homes took 49 days, compared with 55.
Zettergren believes sellers are regaining some negotiating power, but she also sees greater recognition that pandemic-era asking prices aren't necessarily realistic today.
Buyers, she adds, are often more interested in newer roofs, impact-resistant windows and updated mechanical systems than expensive cosmetic improvements.
Yet beneath October's encouraging selling conditions is a potential warning.
New pending single-family sales, representing homes going under contract, declined 12 percent in Sarasota County and 6.3 percent in Manatee. Sarasota condo and townhome contracts fell 6.5 percent, while Manatee's were unchanged. That suggests buyer activity may be cooling, even as completed sales reflect deals negotiated earlier.
Zettergren, however, remains optimistic about the approaching winter season.
"We are busier than ever," she says, noting that last year's seasonal activity began earlier than usual and remained relatively strong through the summer. She expects another busy season as winter visitors return.
For now, October's numbers suggest a housing market finding its footing, but not necessarily for everyone at once. Wealthier buyers remain active, cash offers carry weight, and sellers are gaining ground.