The Book of Moving

Broadway Producer Robert Bartner Lists Sarasota Condo

From "The Book of Mormon" to "Legally Blonde," the Tony Award-winning producer has another production underway: selling his $895,000 Sarasota condo.

By Kim Doleatto November 16, 2026

Bay Plaza in downtown Sarasota.

Robert G. Bartner has helped bring The Book of Mormon, Legally Blonde, Boeing-Boeing and The Lehman Trilogy to the stage. He's collected Tony Awards, worked with some of theater's biggest names and witnessed enough backstage drama to fill several seasons of Company.

Now, at 91, the producer is preparing for a different kind of closing: the sale of his downtown Sarasota condominium.

The second-floor condo has treetop views.

The asking price is $895,000, and while the two-bedroom residence doesn't come with a Broadway marquee, its next owner will inherit something harder to find in a real estate listing: the bragging rights to a home once occupied by an award-winning producer. Elle Woods might recommend a bend and snap to attract a buyer, but this condo has a much better pickup line: “A Tony winner used to live here.”

The 1,822-square-foot condo is on the second floor of Bay Plaza, the Tim Seibert-designed building at 1255 N. Gulfstream Ave. in the heart of downtown Sarasota. The interiors are coastal contemporary, with two en-suite bedrooms, custom cabinetry, two balconies and glimpses of Sarasota Bay through the trees.

The condo spans 1,822 square feet.

Completed in 1983, the 14-story, 100-unit condominium was designed to make the most of a constrained downtown lot and its views of the bayfront. Deep balconies, shade trees and carefully positioned exterior walls help shield residents from the sun and the traffic below. More than four decades later, the building remains a recognizable part of Sarasota's waterfront skyline.

Seibert, who died in 2018, was a pioneering figure in the Sarasota School of Architecture. A protégé of celebrated modernist architect Paul Rudolph, Seibert founded his Sarasota firm in 1955 and became known for designs that combined clean, modernist lines with thoughtful responses to the region's subtropical climate.

There's no elaborate set design here. Bartner, whose professional life has encompassed everything from the razzle-dazzle of Moulin Rouge! to the irreverence of The Book of Mormon, prefers to leave the theatrics at the theater.

Kitchen

"I think that the condo represents a simple but clean, well-proportioned look," he says. "I never thought of it in the context of a refuge from the hustle and bustle of the West End in London or Broadway in New York, but it is somewhat of a refuge."

Of course, a Broadway producer can't escape some drama. Bay Plaza residents have spent years fighting a proposed luxury condominium tower next door once called Obsidian, now known as 1260 North Palm Residences, an 18-story building that would stand higher than its neighbors. On Nov. 2, Sarasota city commissioners rejected the project for a third time, against a special magistrate's recommendation to approve it. The dispute could still wind up in court. 

Bartner has followed the controversy. He worries that relentless high-rise construction is changing the character of the city he fell in love with. But Bay Plaza's west-facing water views wouldn't be obstructed by the proposed tower, which would rise on the opposite, North Palm Avenue side of the building.

The condo’s second bedroom served as Bartner’s home office, with sliding glass doors opening onto a balcony overlooking the trees.

His own second-floor condo offers a look at the bay through the trees—a view he affectionately describes as "peek-a-boo." The water makes a cameo, rather than taking the starring role.

Bartner's favorite room wasn't the primary suite or the living room but the second bedroom, which he claimed as his office. Surrounded by the leafy canopy outside, it offered a quiet place to start his mornings.

One of two bedrooms.

"The second bedroom is actually in the treetops," he says. "I'm an earlier riser than my wife, so that's where I would have my morning coffee and work." 

Entry area

Bartner's theatrical career began with a relatively modest investment—and a fairly improbable choice of production.

While serving on the board of Connecticut's Long Wharf Theatre, he encountered Wit, a play about a university professor confronting terminal ovarian cancer. He loved it. When the production needed $25,000 to make the move to New York, he wrote the check.

Bedroom

Wit went on to enjoy a successful Off Broadway run, and Bartner was hooked.

"I said, 'This is fun. If I love it, it'll work,'" he recalls.

It's an admirably optimistic beginning. One can almost hear strains of "I Believe" from The Book of Mormon beginning to swell. Then came the reality check. "It's not easy," he admits. "[Even] if I love it, it doesn't always work, but that began my journey."

What followed was a career spanning Broadway and London's West End, with producing credits on Legally Blonde, Company, To Kill a Mockingbird, Moulin Rouge! The Musical and The Lehman Trilogy, among others.

His personal favorite musical is The Book of Mormon, the irreverent hit from the creators of "South Park." "We went to a workshop of it. It was hysterically funny and I decided to be part of it," he says. "It's just a wonderful, funny musical."

Balcony

Then there's Boeing-Boeing, the madcap French farce that earned Bartner a Tony Award for the 2008 Broadway revival—and a lasting friendship with actor Mark Rylance.

"There's no great intellectual value to it. It's also very funny," Bartner says. The production had another advantage: Rylance, whom Bartner considers among the finest Shakespearean actors. Their friendship continued through other productions, including Jerusalem, which Bartner also counts among his favorites.

One of two full bathrooms.

Of course, not every production ends with applause. Bartner has also learned that the occasional backstage villain isn't necessarily playing one onstage. As anyone familiar with Boeing-Boeing knows, keeping all the moving parts in the air can get complicated.

He calls one recurring occupational hazard "the dictatorship of the director," referring to directors who refuse to consider a producer's suggestions.

His solution? Don't work with them again.

Bartner and his wife, Beverly, arrived in Sarasota in 2010 after spending winters in St. Croix in the U.S. Virgin Islands. They considered other Florida destinations, including Naples and the state's East Coast, but Sarasota's cultural offerings won them over.

"It was the only place in Florida that we found that offered a full range of the performing arts," he says.

The couple brought their enthusiasm for the arts with them. Beverly's particular passion is opera, while Bartner gravitates toward theater. He served on the board of Asolo Repertory Theatre, as a trustee of Ringling College of Art and Design and on the Sarasota Memorial Healthcare Foundation board.

Bay Plaza placed the couple within walking distance of Florida Studio Theatre, Sarasota Opera House, restaurants, the bayfront and the Saturday farmers market.

A heated lap pool is among the plaza's amenities.

And although Bartner's theater résumé might suggest a preference for lavish surroundings, what he valued most was the ability to escape the hustle and bustle whenever he wished.

"The condo was the perfect refuge in the middle of a vibrant city," he says. "We love vibrant cities. It's great. But it's also nice to be able to go home, close your door, and be in a quiet, peaceful place."

The building's 24-hour concierge, valet parking, heated pool, spa and other amenities helped make that possible. The condo, which the Bartners purchased after its previous owners remodeled it, provided an easygoing counterpoint to a career spent navigating theatrical personalities and productions.

Exterior entryway tucked away from North Palm Avenue.

Still, even the most successful productions eventually reach their final performance.

The Bartners returned to Connecticut in 2025 to be closer to family, though they held on to the Sarasota residence. Bartner says they may still return for winter visits. Their Sarasota story may be on intermission rather than permanently closed.

Lobby

The condo enters a downtown market where seven-figure asking prices are hardly unusual, and a listing under $1 million can feel like a steal. In September, the median listing price across all residential property types in downtown Sarasota was roughly $900,000, according to Realtor.com. Across Sarasota County, condo and townhouse sales rose 26.8 percent in the third quarter compared with a year earlier, while available inventory fell 12 percent.

The numbers point to an audience for Sarasota condos. But Bartner has a more personal way of remembering his years here.

Asked what he'd call the story of his Sarasota life if it were a Broadway show, he offers a title worthy of a marquee.

"The Bay Plaza Follies," he says.

The next cast has yet to be announced.

Interested? Contact Laura Pearson at (941) 993-5167 or Bonnie Stein at (914) 262-0915, of Premier Sotheby's International Realty. 

Share
Show Comments