Both the beguiling woman pictured in the logo and the romantic name imply
that dinner at Ophelia's on the Bay should be a grown-up gourmet adventure. And
that expectation continues to be expertly fulfilled at this long-running
Sarasota classic. Ophelia's seats 150, and the inside dining areas has windows
overlooking Little Sarasota Bay. Outside, a covered terrace and a stone patio
offer even closer proximity to the pretty view, while a weathered wooden deck
almost puts diners in the water near the outcroppings of mangroves. Arrive by
car or by boat (marker 48).
Tourists usually want the outdoor areas, as do smokers. Locals often select a
table inside in one of the climate-controlled dining rooms to settle in for an
intimate, unhurried meal while gazing at stars reflected as liquid silver on the
surface of water.
The low-ceilinged burgundy and cream main dining room is cozy with its
double-cloaked tables, comfortable armchairs and candle lamps of gold beading.
The experienced serving staff in semi-formal attire is well versed in the menu
and wine list. When you're seated, a basket of dense, chewy, warm bread arrives
with a ramekin of plain butter and one containing fragrant roasted garlic.
The menu, which underwent major changes when 44-year-old executive chef Mitch
Rosenbaum arrived in 1999, is California-inspired (for example, almond, fig and
goat cheese strudel) with a respectful nod to regional seafood favorites, fusion
fantasies and a few classics such as duck and veal chops. Entrées average about
$27, and your plate will include crunchy fresh vegetables and a starch-sometimes
a delightfully unexpected one, such as jasmine rice, vanilla-whipped sweet
potato, baked acorn squash topped with pear, or creamy tomato risotto studded
with mushrooms. Soba noodles accompany one of the tuna dishes. Here's a chef who
can see beyond garlic mashed potatoes!
Other unusual items should excite even the most jaded foodie. Consider a
black truffle, three-cheese ravioli, braised Swiss chard, maple-roasted duck
with mulled cider, or medallions of antelope sirloin arranged on the plate with
venison bratwurst and finished with a sun-dried cherry glaze and cognac. The
Maine lobster is stuffed with acorn squash. A full Jamaican jerk treatment is
bestowed on the pork tenderloin, for carnivores who want a little kick to their
meat.
Rosenbaum has also introduced a game rotation, which includes antelope,
pheasant, bison, venison and more. He searches for small farms cultivating
free-range animals. With an affection for Asian and Indian cuisines, the chef is
constantly experimenting with unexpected ways to serve game. But Rosenbaum also
takes pride in his cornmeal-coated Key West yellow snapper served with refried
beans, fried plantains and lump crabmeat guacamole. He calls this plate
high-tech Mexican. And the sesame-crusted yellowfin tuna is a consistent winner.
Rosenbaum has owned two restaurants in Cape Cod and has been cooking
professionally for 26 years. He has special expertise with French Moroccan
dishes and American seafood favorites.
The extensive wine menu ranks among the half-dozen best in Sarasota. It's
balanced primarily between American and French offerings with a fair number of
other nations, including Italy, Spain, and Germany. The restaurant offers 17
wines by the glass ($7-$11). Our choice with our antelope and veal entrées was a
'98 Villa Mount Eden Grand Reserve Syrah ($49). The list also offers some lush,
potent reds for all-game meals.
Happily, Ophelia's is a restaurant that believes in a big finish. Pastry chef
Christine Nordstrom creates lavish goodies and changes the lineup seasonally.
Still, some favorites remain, like the chiffon key lime pie so many tourists
love. Another crowd-pleaser is the hazelnut white chocolate mouse pillowed in a
dark, chocolate-lined pastry cup that rests in a pond of fresh berries and
coulis. It looks as brilliant as it tastes. Comfort-food lovers need look no
further than the warm, walnut bread pudding.
Ophelia's On The Bay was established in 1989 by Stanley Ferro. By local
standards, this place is positively historic; a fine-dining restaurant that
consistently satisfies whether you are scouting an unusual meal expertly
prepared or celebrating a special occasion. Excellent food, wine, service,
setting-Ophelia's On The Bay continues to furnish it all.